How to Do Payroll: Complete Small Business Guide [2025]

Learning how to do payroll can feel like trying to solve a puzzle while blindfolded. One wrong calculation, one missed deadline, and suddenly you're dealing with angry employees and IRS penalties that can cost thousands.

Companies have an average payroll accuracy rate of 80.15%, with businesses making an average of 15 errors per payroll period. For small businesses, these mistakes are expensive and can be devastating.

But payroll doesn't have to be your nemesis.

Whether you're planning to handle it yourself, invest in payroll software, or outsource to professionals, this guide walks you through every option. We'll cover the real costs, the hidden gotchas, and exactly what you need to know to pay your team accurately and on time.

You've got a business to run. Let's make sure payroll helps instead of hurts.

TL;DR: What you need to know about how to do payroll

Is it hard to learn how to do payroll? Learning basic payroll isn't hard, but staying compliant with changing tax laws requires ongoing attention. Most small business owners master the fundamentals in 2-3 pay periods, but complexity grows with your team size.

What are the steps to process payroll? The payroll process boils down to five essential steps: calculate gross pay, withhold taxes and deductions, determine net pay, process payments, and file required tax forms. Each step has specific requirements and deadlines.

Can you do payroll yourself? Yes, but success depends on three factors: time availability (2-4 hours per pay period), basic math skills, and attention to detail. DIY works best for businesses with 1-5 employees and straightforward pay structures.

How do you calculate payroll? Start with hours worked × hourly rate for gross pay. Subtract pre-tax deductions (health insurance, retirement), then tax withholdings (federal, state, FICA), then post-tax deductions for net pay. We'll show you exact examples below.

{{banner-cta}}

Getting started: Your payroll foundation

Before you can figure out how to do payroll, you need to lay the groundwork. Think of this as building the foundation of your house—skip these steps, and everything else gets shaky fast.

The good news? Most of this setup is one-time work that takes a few weeks to complete.

Apply for your Employer Identification Number (EIN)

Your EIN is basically your business's Social Security number—you'll need it for everything from opening bank accounts to filing taxes. The IRS requires it before you can legally pay employees.

Getting your EIN is surprisingly simple:

• Apply online for free at IRS.gov (takes about 15 minutes)
• You'll receive it immediately for online applications
• Mail applications take 4-5 weeks, so don't wait
• Phone applications are available for international businesses

You'll need your EIN for:

• Opening business bank accounts
• Setting up payroll software
• Filing quarterly tax forms
• Applying for business licenses

Keep your EIN confirmation letter somewhere safe—you'll reference it constantly during your first year.

Register with state and local tax agencies

The federal government isn't the only one who wants to know about your payroll. Most states require separate registration for unemployment insurance and state income tax withholding.

State requirements typically include:

• Unemployment insurance registration - Usually through your state's Department of Labor
• State income tax withholding - If your state has income tax
• Workers' compensation insurance - Required in most states before hiring
• New hire reporting system - Background check and verification setup

Timeline reality check: Start this process 2-3 weeks before you plan to hire anyone. Some states move fast, others don't. You don't want to delay someone's start date because you're waiting for paperwork.

Local considerations: Some cities and counties have their own payroll taxes. Philadelphia, New York City, and San Francisco are notorious for this. A quick Google search for "[your city] payroll tax" can save you headaches later.

Set up your payroll bank account

You're not required to have a separate payroll account, but it's one of those "trust us on this" recommendations. When payroll money gets mixed with operating funds, mistakes happen.

Why separate accounts matter:

• Clearer record-keeping - No guessing which transactions were payroll
• Better security - If one account gets compromised, the other stays safe
• Easier tax preparation - Your accountant will thank you
• Cash flow management - Know exactly how much you need for payroll

What to look for in a payroll account:

• Low or no monthly fees
• Free electronic transfers
• Good online banking platform
• Easy integration with payroll software

Funding strategy: Many businesses transfer payroll money into this account a few days before each pay period. Others keep a month's worth of payroll as a buffer. Find what works for your cash flow.

Gather required employee forms

You can't run payroll without proper employee documentation. The government is very specific about what you need and when you need it.

Essential forms for every employee:

• Form I-9 - Employment eligibility verification (must be completed by day 3)
• Form W-4 - Federal income tax withholding certificate
• State withholding forms - Required in most states with income tax
• Direct deposit authorization - Banking information for electronic payments

Beyond the basics:

• Emergency contact information
• Benefits enrollment forms
• Acknowledgment of employee handbook receipt
• Any required industry-specific certifications

Organization tip: Create a digital folder for each employee with all their forms. Paper gets lost, computers get backed up. Tools like Homebase's digital onboarding system can store all these documents electronically, making them searchable and accessible when you need them most.

This foundation work might feel tedious, but it's what separates businesses that run smooth payroll from those dealing with compliance nightmares. Get it right once, and you'll save yourself countless hours of cleanup later.

The 5-step payroll process explained

Once your foundation is solid, learning how to do payroll comes down to mastering these five core steps. Every business—whether you're running a coffee shop with three employees or managing a retail chain—follows this same basic process.

The complexity might scale, but the framework never changes.

Step 1: Track and calculate gross pay

This is where the rubber meets the road. Gross pay is the total amount you owe employees before any deductions—and getting it wrong here means everything downstream gets messed up.

For hourly employees, the basic formula is simple:

• Regular hours (up to 40 per week) × hourly rate
• Overtime hours × overtime rate (typically 1.5× regular rate)
• Add any bonuses, commissions, or shift differentials

Real-world example: Marcus works 42 hours at $20/hour at your restaurant. Here's how it breaks down:

• Regular pay: 40 hours × $20 = $800
• Overtime pay: 2 hours × $30 (1.5 × $20) = $60
• Total gross pay: $860

Overtime rules vary by state:

• Federal minimum: 1.5× rate after 40 hours per week
• California, Alaska, Nevada: Also require overtime after 8 hours per day
• Some states: Double-time for excessive hours (over 12/day in California)

Common gross pay mistakes:

• Forgetting to include tips or bonuses
• Using regular rate instead of overtime rate
• Miscounting hours due to poor time tracking
• Not accounting for shift premiums or weekend differentials

Time tracking reality: Paper timesheets lead to errors. Whether you use a simple time clock app or integrated scheduling software, digital tracking eliminates most gross pay mistakes.

Step 2: Calculate payroll deductions and withholdings

Here's where payroll gets tricky. You're not just an employer—you're also a tax collector for multiple government agencies. The order of deductions matters because some reduce taxable income while others don't.

Pre-tax deductions (subtract these first):

• Health insurance premiums
• Dental and vision insurance
• 401(k) contributions
• Flexible spending accounts (FSA)
• Parking or transit benefits

Tax withholdings (calculated on reduced income after pre-tax deductions):

• Federal income tax - Based on W-4 information
• Social Security tax - 6.2% of gross wages (up to annual limit)
• Medicare tax - 1.45% of all wages
• State income tax - Varies by state (some states have none)
• Local taxes - City or county taxes where applicable

Post-tax deductions (after all taxes):

• Roth IRA contributions
• Union dues
• Wage garnishments (court-ordered)
• Voluntary life insurance premiums

Continuing Marcus's example ($860 gross pay):

• Pre-tax deductions: $85 (health insurance)
• Taxable income: $775
• Federal income tax: $116 (15% bracket, single filer)
• Social Security: $48 (6.2% of $775)
• Medicare: $11 (1.45% of $775)
• State tax: $31 (4% rate)
• Total deductions: $291

The W-4 impact: More allowances mean less federal tax withheld. Zero allowances means maximum withholding. When employees update their W-4, their take-home pay changes immediately.

Step 3: Calculate net pay

This is the easy math: gross pay minus all deductions equals net pay. But double-checking your work here can save you from costly mistakes.

Using Marcus's numbers:

• Gross pay: $860
• Total deductions: $291
• Net pay: $569

Red flags to watch for:

• Net pay that seems unusually high or low
• Deductions that exceed gross pay
• Tax withholdings that don't make sense for the employee's situation
• Missing deductions (forgetting health insurance or 401k)

Does this paycheck look reasonable compared to previous pay periods? Big swings usually mean something went wrong.

Step 4: Process payments and distribute paystubs

Payment day is when your payroll accuracy gets tested by the people who matter most—your employees.

Payment method considerations:

• Direct deposit - Preferred by most employees, faster and more secure
• Paper checks - Still required in some states if employees request it
• Pay cards - Good option for employees without bank accounts

Paystub requirements vary by state, but generally include:

• Employee name and address
• Pay period dates
• Hours worked (for hourly employees)
• Gross pay breakdown
• All deductions listed separately
• Net pay amount
• Year-to-date totals

Timing matters: Most states have strict requirements about when you must pay employees. Weekly, biweekly, and semi-monthly are most common, but check your state's rules.

Employees should never be surprised by their paycheck amount. If there are changes to deductions or unusual overtime, give them a heads up.

Step 5: File taxes and maintain records

This step separates compliant businesses from those facing IRS penalties. The government wants their money on time, with proper documentation.

Quarterly requirements:

• Form 941 - Report income, Social Security, and Medicare taxes
• Tax deposits - Monthly or semi-weekly, depending on your tax liability
• State quarterly reports - Unemployment and income tax filings

Annual obligations:

• Form 940 - Federal unemployment tax return
• W-2s - Employee wage statements (due January 31)
• 1099-NEC - Non-employee compensation for contractors

Record retention requirements:

• 3 years minimum - Payroll records, timecards, W-4s (FLSA requirement)
• 4 years - Employment tax records (IRS requirement)
• Until resolved - Any records related to disputes or audits

The penalty reality: Late tax deposits cost 2-15% of the unpaid amount. Late 941 forms cost 5% per month, up to 25%. These aren't suggestions—they're expensive requirements.

Modern payroll systems handle tax calculations, deposits, and filings automatically. Tools like Homebase's payroll automation eliminate the manual tracking and calculation work, ensuring you meet deadlines and file forms correctly—so you can focus on running your business instead of becoming a tax expert.

These five steps form the backbone of every payroll process. Master them, and you've got the foundation for paying your team accurately and staying compliant as you grow.

{{banner-cta}}

How to do payroll: Your three options

Now that you understand the payroll process, you've got three ways to handle it. Each approach has different time commitments, costs, and complexity levels.

The trick is matching your choice to your business's current needs while planning for where you're headed.

Option 1: Do payroll yourself (DIY method)

Going the DIY route means you're handling every calculation, tax lookup, and form filing personally. It's the hands-on approach that gives you complete control—and complete responsibility.

What's actually involved:

• Manually calculating gross pay for each employee
• Looking up current tax tables and rates
• Computing all deductions and withholdings by hand
• Preparing and filing quarterly tax forms
• Writing checks or managing direct deposits
• Maintaining detailed payroll records

Time investment reality check: Plan on 2-4 hours per pay period for 5-10 employees. That might not sound like much, but it adds up fast. For a biweekly payroll, you're looking at 52-104 hours per year—more than two full work weeks.

The true cost breakdown:

• Software/tools: $0-50 per month (spreadsheets, calculators)
• Your time: 50-100 hours annually
• Mistake costs: Potentially thousands in penalties and corrections
• Stress factor: High, especially around tax deadlines

DIY makes sense when you have:

• 1-3 employees maximum
• Simple hourly pay with minimal benefits
• Strong accounting or bookkeeping background
• Plenty of time to dedicate to payroll tasks
• High tolerance for detailed, repetitive work

Real scenario: Sarah runs a small bakery with two part-time employees. Same hourly rates, no benefits, weekly pay schedule. She spends about 90 minutes each week on payroll and has never made a major mistake. For her, DIY works.

The hidden costs nobody talks about:

• Learning tax law changes each year
• Staying current on state and local requirements
• Time spent fixing inevitable mistakes
• Lost sleep during tax season
• Opportunity cost of time spent on payroll vs. growing the business

Pros:

• Complete control over the process
• No monthly software fees
• Deep understanding of your payroll costs
• Immediate access to all records

Cons:

• High error risk, especially with tax calculations
• Extremely time-intensive as you grow
• No compliance support or automatic updates
• Manual tax filing and record-keeping
• Personal liability for mistakes

Option 2: Use payroll software

Payroll software sits in the sweet spot between control and convenience. You're still involved in the process, but the heavy lifting—calculations, tax tables, compliance updates—gets handled automatically.

What's involved with software:

• Entering basic employee information and hours
• Reviewing calculated payroll for accuracy
• Approving direct deposits or check runs
• Software handles tax calculations and filings
• Digital record-keeping and reporting

Time investment: About 30-60 minutes per pay period, regardless of team size. The software scales with your business while your time investment stays roughly the same.

Cost expectations: Most small business payroll software runs $40-150 per month, plus $2-8 per employee. For a team of 10, expect to pay $60-230 monthly. Sounds expensive until you calculate the value of your time.

Key features that matter:

• Automated tax calculations - No more looking up rates
• Direct deposit processing - Employees get paid faster
• Tax filing and payments - Quarterly forms filed automatically
• Employee self-service - Workers can access paystubs and tax forms
• Integration capabilities - Works with your existing tools
• Compliance updates - Software stays current with law changes

Software evaluation criteria: When you're comparing options, focus on these factors:

Ease of use: Can you figure out payroll without reading a manual? If the interface confuses you during the demo, it'll be worse under deadline pressure.

Customer support: Can you reach a human when problems arise? Check support hours, response times, and whether phone support costs extra.

Scalability: Will it grow with your business? Consider features like multi-location support, advanced reporting, and employee limits.

Integration: Does it play well with your other tools? Time tracking, accounting software, and HR systems should connect seamlessly.

Compliance coverage: How well does it handle your specific situation? Multi-state businesses, union requirements, and industry-specific rules need specialized support.

Leading solutions comparison:

Homebase: Built specifically for hourly teams with integrated time tracking and scheduling. Flat-rate pricing eliminates per-employee fees, making it cost-effective as you grow. Strong mobile app for managers and employees.

Gusto: User-friendly interface with solid benefits administration. Good for businesses wanting to offer health insurance and retirement plans. Tiered pricing can get expensive with larger teams.

QuickBooks Payroll: Seamless integration with QuickBooks accounting. Established platform with comprehensive features. Higher cost but extensive functionality.

ADP: Enterprise-grade features with professional support. Best for larger teams or complex needs. Premium pricing reflects comprehensive service.

When software makes the most sense:

• 4+ employees or rapid growth plans
• Hourly workers with varying schedules
• Multiple pay rates or regular overtime
• Limited time to spend on payroll tasks
• Want compliance support without full outsourcing
• Need integration with scheduling or accounting tools

Modern payroll software eliminates the manual work that creates errors. Tax tables update automatically, overtime calculations happen instantly, and compliance requirements get built into the workflow. Tools like Homebase's integrated platform go further by combining time tracking, scheduling, and payroll—so your team's hours flow directly into their paychecks without manual data entry.

Pros:

• Dramatically reduced error risk
• Saves significant time each pay period
• Automatic compliance and tax updates
• Scales easily as your business grows
• Professional support when needed
• Integration with other business tools

Cons:

• Monthly subscription costs
• Learning curve with new software
• Still requires review and approval
• Dependent on internet connectivity

Option 3: Outsource to professionals

Full payroll outsourcing means handing over the entire process to specialists. You provide employee data and hours, they handle everything else—calculations, filings, compliance, problem-solving.

What's involved:

• Submitting employee hours and any changes
• Reviewing payroll summaries before processing
• Receiving completed payroll and reports
• Provider handles all tax filings and payments
• Full compliance management and support

Time investment: About 15-30 minutes per pay period for data submission and review. The provider does the rest.

Cost reality: Full-service payroll typically costs $150-300 per employee annually, or 2-4% of total payroll. For specialized industries or complex needs, costs can be higher.

Outsourcing makes sense when:

• 15+ employees with complex needs
• Multiple locations or states
• Industry-specific compliance requirements
• High-value executive time better spent elsewhere
• Need for comprehensive HR support
• Low tolerance for payroll-related stress

Pros:

• Minimal time investment required
• Professional expertise and liability coverage
• Comprehensive compliance management
• Scalable for complex, multi-state operations
• Dedicated support team

Cons:

• Highest cost option
• Less direct control over timing and processes
• Dependency on external provider
• May require long-term contracts

Making the right choice for your business

Your decision shouldn't just be about today—think about where you'll be in two years. A solution that works for 3 employees might crumble at 15.

Quick decision framework:

• 1-3 employees, simple structure → DIY might work
• 4-15 employees, growing → Payroll software is your sweet spot
• 15+ employees, complex needs → Consider outsourcing

Most businesses evolve from DIY to software to outsourcing as they grow. Plan for transitions at natural breakpoints—new fiscal years or major hiring phases—to minimize disruption.

{{banner-cta}}

Payroll calculations made simple

Learning how to calculate payroll doesn't have to involve a math degree. Once you see the formula in action with real numbers, the process becomes straightforward.

Let's walk through an actual payroll calculation so you can see exactly how the money flows from gross pay to what employees take home.

Real payroll calculation example

Meet Elena Rodriguez, a shift supervisor at your retail store who earns $24/hour and worked 44 hours this week.

Step 1: Calculate gross pay

• Regular hours: 40 × $24 = $960
• Overtime hours: 4 × $36 (1.5 × $24) = $144
• Total gross pay: $1,104

Step 2: Subtract pre-tax deductions

• Health insurance: $125/month ÷ 2 pay periods = $62.50
• 401(k) contribution: 3% of gross = $33.12
• Subtotal after pre-tax deductions: $1,008.38

Step 3: Calculate tax withholdings (based on adjusted amount)

• Federal income tax: $151 (15% bracket, married filing jointly)
• Social Security: $62.52 (6.2% of $1,008.38)
• Medicare: $14.62 (1.45% of $1,008.38)
• State income tax: $40.34 (4% rate)
• Total tax withholdings: $268.48

Step 4: Subtract post-tax deductions

• Union dues: $25
• Final net pay: $1,008.38 - $268.48 - $25 = $714.90

Elena worked 44 hours and earned $1,104 gross, but took home $714.90—about 65% of her gross pay. That's typical for someone with benefits and moderate tax withholdings.

Overtime calculation rules by state

Understanding overtime gets tricky because states have different rules beyond federal requirements.

Federal standard (applies everywhere):

• 1.5× regular rate for hours over 40 per week
• No daily overtime requirement

States with daily overtime rules:

• California: 1.5× after 8 hours/day, 2× after 12 hours/day
• Alaska: 1.5× after 8 hours/day
• Nevada: 1.5× after 8 hours/day (with exceptions)

Common overtime mistakes:

• Using regular rate instead of 1.5× rate
• Forgetting daily overtime in applicable states
• Miscalculating rates for employees with multiple pay levels
• Not including shift differentials in overtime calculations

If you're manually tracking overtime rules across multiple states or dealing with complex pay structures, you're setting yourself up for expensive mistakes. Modern payroll systems automatically apply the correct overtime rules based on your location and employee classifications—eliminating the guesswork that leads to underpayment penalties and upset employees.

Payroll math isn't complicated once you understand the sequence. The challenge is staying current with tax rates, overtime rules, and deduction changes. Get the formula right, and you're halfway to running accurate payroll.

Payroll compliance essentials

Getting the math right is only half the battle when you're learning how to do payroll. The other half is staying compliant with a web of federal, state, and local regulations that change regularly.

Miss a deadline or file the wrong form, and you'll discover just how expensive compliance mistakes can be.

Required federal forms and deadlines

The IRS doesn't mess around with payroll tax deadlines. Here's your compliance roadmap for staying out of trouble.

Quarterly obligations:

• Form 941 (Employer's quarterly federal tax return): Due by the last day of the month following each quarter
• Tax deposits: Schedule depends on your total tax liability
  
  • Under $2,500 quarterly: Pay with Form 941
  • Over $2,500: Monthly or semi-weekly deposits required

Annual requirements:

• Form 940 (Federal unemployment tax return): Due January 31
• W-2s for employees: Provide to workers and file with SSA by January 31
• 1099-NEC for contractors: Provide to recipients and file with IRS by January 31

The penalty reality:

• Late deposits: 2% (1-5 days late) up to 15% (after IRS notice)
• Late 941 filing: 5% per month, maximum 25%
• Missing W-2s: $310 per form if filed after August 1

The IRS Electronic Federal Tax Payment System (EFTPS) is mandatory for federal tax deposits. Set up your account before you need it—the approval process takes time.

Record keeping requirements

Documentation isn't just good business practice—it's legally required. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) and IRS have specific retention rules that protect you during audits.

Minimum retention periods:

• 3 years: Employee records, timecards, payroll registers, W-4 forms
• 4 years: Tax returns and supporting documents
• 7 years: Records supporting tax deductions and credits

What to keep accessible:

• Employee personal information and job classifications
• Dates and hours worked each day
• Regular and overtime earnings records
• Total daily or weekly straight-time and overtime wages
• Deductions from or additions to wages
• Total wages paid each pay period

Digital storage beats paper every time. Scan physical documents immediately and store them in organized folders by tax year. Cloud backup ensures you won't lose critical records to hardware failures or disasters.

Employee classification rules

Misclassifying workers is one of the most expensive payroll mistakes you can make. The Department of Labor and IRS take this seriously, and the penalties reflect it.

Exempt vs. non-exempt employees:

• Salary threshold: $844 per week minimum for exempt status
• Duties test: Must perform executive, administrative, or professional work
• Salary basis: Must receive full salary regardless of hours worked

Independent contractor vs. employee: The IRS uses a three-factor test:

• Behavioral control: Do you control how the work is done?
• Financial control: Who provides tools, materials, and covers expenses?
• Relationship type: Ongoing work relationship vs. project-based?

Misclassification consequences:

• Back wages and overtime payments
• Employment taxes plus penalties and interest
• Workers' compensation and unemployment insurance costs
• Potential lawsuits from affected workers

When in doubt: Classify as an employee. The penalties for misclassifying employees as contractors are severe, while the reverse rarely creates problems.

Some states like California have stricter classification tests than federal requirements. Always check your state's specific rules.

Compliance isn't optional, and ignorance isn't a defense. The regulations seem overwhelming because they are—but staying current with requirements is part of the cost of having employees. Whether you handle compliance yourself or rely on payroll software that stays updated automatically, make sure someone is watching the details that keep your business protected.

Common payroll mistakes (and how to avoid them)

Even when you know how to do payroll correctly, mistakes happen. The difference between a minor hiccup and a business-threatening problem is catching errors early and knowing how to prevent them from recurring.

Here are the costly payroll mistakes that trip up small business owners most often—and the practical steps to avoid them.

Math errors and calculation mishaps

Small calculation errors create big problems when they compound over time. A $2/hour mistake might seem minor until you realize it's costing $4,160 per year for just one full-time employee.

The most expensive calculation mistakes:

• Overtime rate errors: Using $20/hour instead of $30/hour for overtime adds up fast
• Rounding inconsistencies: Rounding each step instead of final totals creates cumulative errors
• Benefit deduction mix-ups: Using old insurance rates or forgetting contribution changes
• Tax table mistakes: Applying wrong brackets or using outdated withholding percentages

Prevention strategies that work:

• Double-check formulas before payroll runs: Verify overtime rates match current pay scales
• Use consistent rounding rules: Round only the final net pay amount, never intermediate calculations
• Create calculation checklists: Document your process so you don't skip steps under pressure
• Spot-check results: If a paycheck looks unusual, investigate before processing

A restaurant owner accidentally used regular rates for all overtime hours during a busy holiday week. The error affected 8 employees and cost $640 in back wages, plus penalties and the time to issue correction payments.

Missed deadlines and filing failures

Timing mistakes cost more than calculation errors because the government charges penalties immediately, regardless of whether you eventually file correctly.

Deadline disasters that drain bank accounts:

• Quarterly 941 forms: Missing the last day of the month following each quarter
• Tax deposit schedules: Confusing monthly vs. semi-weekly deposit requirements
• Year-end W-2 distribution: January 31 deadline applies to both employees and government filing
• New hire reporting: Most states require reporting within 20 days of hire date

Creating foolproof deadline systems:

• Calendar automation: Set recurring reminders 1 week before each deadline
• Batch similar tasks: Process all quarterly requirements during the same week
• Backup person training: Ensure someone else can handle filings if you're unavailable
• Early submission habit: File forms and make deposits 2-3 days early when possible

Missing a quarterly 941 filing triggers multiple penalties—late filing, late payment, and potential failure-to-pay charges that compound monthly until resolved.

Employee information and record errors

Incomplete or incorrect employee data causes problems that ripple through every aspect of payroll, from daily calculations to year-end tax forms.

Information gaps that cause headaches:

• Missing or expired I-9 forms: Creates compliance violations during audits
• Outdated W-4 information: Results in incorrect tax withholdings and angry employees
• Wrong Social Security numbers: Prevents proper tax reporting and creates W-2 rejections
• Incomplete direct deposit details: Causes failed payments and frustrated workers

Record-keeping systems that prevent problems:

• Digital employee folders: Store all forms electronically with backup copies
• Annual W-4 reviews: Remind employees to update withholdings after major life changes
• Quarterly data audits: Verify Social Security numbers, addresses, and banking information
• Change documentation: Track all employee updates with dates and approval signatures

Technology and process failures

Over-relying on manual processes or outdated systems creates unnecessary risk in an area where accuracy is critical.

System weaknesses that create costly errors:

• Spreadsheet dependency: Manual entry errors multiply as your team grows
• Paper timesheet problems: Lost cards, illegible handwriting, and calculation mistakes
• Lack of backup procedures: Single points of failure that can derail entire pay periods
• No verification processes: Missing the second set of eyes that catches mistakes

Building resilient payroll operations:

• Implement verification steps: Have different people handle data entry and review
• Regular system backups: Protect payroll data with automated cloud storage
• Error-checking protocols: Build validation rules into your processes
• Process documentation: Write down your procedures so they survive staff changes

Modern payroll systems eliminate most of these common errors automatically. Tools like Homebase's integrated payroll system combine time tracking with payroll processing, reducing manual data entry while providing built-in verification checks that catch mistakes before they become expensive problems.

Every business makes payroll mistakes eventually. The key is learning from them, improving your processes, and choosing systems that reduce the likelihood of expensive errors repeating themselves.

Choosing the right payroll method for your business

The best payroll approach is about what fits your specific situation right now and where you're heading. Making the wrong choice costs more than money—it costs time, stress, and sometimes employee trust when things go wrong.

Decision factors that actually matter

Skip the generic advice about "choosing the right solution." Here's what really determines whether a payroll method will work for your business.

Team size and growth trajectory:

• 1-3 employees, stable: DIY can work if you have the time and skills
• 4-10 employees, growing: Software hits the sweet spot for cost and control
• 10+ employees, rapid growth: Software with scalability features or outsourcing consideration
• Seasonal fluctuations: Look for flexible pricing that adjusts with your workforce

Operational complexity indicators:

• Single location, simple hourly rates: Any method works
• Multiple locations or states: Software with multi-location features essential
• Variable schedules and overtime: Integration with time tracking becomes critical
• Tips, commissions, or piece rates: Specialized calculation features needed

Owner involvement preferences:

• High control needed: DIY or software with manual approval workflows
• Moderate oversight: Software with automated features and exception reporting
• Hands-off approach: Full outsourcing with summary reporting

Risk tolerance assessment:

• Low tolerance for errors: Automated software or professional services
• Comfortable with compliance responsibility: Software with support options
• Prefer delegated liability: Full-service outsourcing with error coverage

Making the switch successfully

Most businesses evolve through payroll methods as they grow. Planning your transition prevents disruption and data loss.

Optimal timing for changes:

• Beginning of calendar year: Cleanest for tax reporting and record-keeping
• Start of fiscal year: Aligns with budget planning and business cycles
• After major hiring phases: When current systems show strain
• Avoid mid-quarter transitions: Complicates tax filing and record continuity

Data migration essentials:

• Year-to-date payroll totals: Critical for tax reporting accuracy
• Employee information and rates: Ensure complete transfer without gaps
• Tax liability balances: Must carry forward correctly
• Historical access plan: Maintain records from previous system

Transition period strategy:

• Run parallel systems: Process 1-2 payrolls with both methods to verify accuracy
• Employee communication: Explain changes to pay dates, access methods, or processes
• Test direct deposits: Verify banking information transfers correctly
• Backup plan: Keep old system accessible until new one proves stable

The key to figuring out how to do payroll that works long-term is matching your method to both current needs and realistic growth projections. Don't choose based on where you hope to be—choose based on where you'll likely be in 12-18 months.

Most small businesses start with DIY, move to software around 5-7 employees, and consider outsourcing after 15-20 employees. But your timeline might be different based on complexity, growth rate, and personal preferences.

{{banner-cta}}

Frequently asked questions

How often should I run payroll?

Most small businesses choose weekly or biweekly for hourly employees—it helps with cash flow and matches how people budget. Check your state's requirements first, as some mandate minimum pay frequencies.

What's the best payroll software for small business?

The "best" depends on your team structure. For hourly teams with varying schedules, look for integrated time tracking. For salary-heavy businesses, focus on benefits administration. Always prioritize ease of use over feature lists.

Can I change payroll methods mid-year?

Yes, but timing matters for tax reporting. Plan transitions for the beginning of quarters to avoid complications with Form 941 filings. Allow 2-4 weeks for setup and data migration.

What happens if I make a payroll mistake?

Fix it immediately with a correction payroll run. Communicate clearly with affected employees about what happened and when they'll receive the adjustment. Document everything for your records.

Do I need workers' compensation insurance to run payroll?

Most states require it before you hire your first employee. It's separate from payroll but affects your total labor costs. Check your state's requirements—penalties for non-compliance are severe.

How long should I keep payroll records?

Three years minimum for timecards and payroll registers (FLSA requirement). Four years for tax documents (IRS requirement). Keep everything digital with cloud backup—paper gets lost.

What if an employee doesn't fill out a W-4?

You must withhold taxes as if they're single with no allowances—the maximum withholding rate. They'll get a smaller paycheck until they submit a completed W-4.

Can I run payroll from my phone?

Most modern payroll software offers mobile apps for approving payroll and basic management. Full setup and complex changes still work better on computers, but mobile access helps for time-sensitive approvals.

Your payroll journey starts here

Learning how to do payroll is like learning to drive—intimidating at first, but manageable once you understand the system. The difference between payroll success and expensive mistakes isn't perfection; it's preparation and choosing the right approach for your business.

Take action today

Don't wait until your next hire to get your payroll foundation ready. Start with the basics that every business needs:

This week:

• Apply for your EIN if you don't have one
• Research your state's payroll tax requirements
• Decide which payroll method fits your current situation

This month:

• Set up your payroll bank account
• Choose and implement your payroll system
• Create employee documentation processes

Ongoing:

• Build relationships with local HR professionals
• Stay informed about tax law changes
• Review your payroll method annually as your business grows

Ready to simplify your payroll?

If you're managing hourly teams and tired of juggling separate systems for scheduling, time tracking, and payroll, Homebase brings it all together in one platform. Our pricing grows with your team without surprise fees, and our support team helps you get set up right the first time.

{{banner-cta}}