If you're looking for Gusto alternatives, you're likely finding that Gusto's pricing, missing scheduling features, or inconsistent support aren't working for you and your hourly team.
Whether you're searching for alternatives to Gusto or comparing Gusto competitors side by side, this guide cuts through the noise. Gusto works well for salaried, remote-first teams, but for businesses with tipped employees, shift schedules, and variable headcount, the gaps start to show.
We walk you through five approaches to payroll for hourly teams, the real costs of choosing the wrong one, and the questions that actually help you find the right fit.
What you need to know about switching from Gusto
Evaluating Gusto alternatives comes down to a few key questions: how your team tracks hours, how often you run payroll, and whether you need scheduling built into the same app. Here's what matters most before you decide.
- Gusto works well for salaried teams but can feel expensive and clunky for hourly workers who need scheduling, time tracking, and payroll connected in one place.
- Hidden payroll fees like setup, per-run charges, year-end W-2/1099 filing, and garnishment processing can add to your annual cost beyond the sticker price.
- The best Gusto alternative depends on your team size, how you track hours, and whether you need scheduling built in.
- All-in-one tools that connect scheduling, time tracking, and payroll cut sync errors and save time every pay period.
{{banner-cta}}
Why Homebase created this list
We build scheduling, time tracking, and payroll for hourly teams. That means we know this space well, and we know Gusto — it's a tool many of our customers used before switching. We put this list together to give small business owners an honest look at what's available, including tools we don't compete with directly.
Gusto earned its reputation with strong payroll automation, clean onboarding, and solid benefits administration. For salaried, office-based teams, it's a genuinely good tool.
Where it gets tricky is hourly work. Scheduling and time tracking aren't included in Gusto's base plan — they're available on higher tiers or as add-ons. Gusto pricing also scales per employee, which can get unpredictable for teams where headcount fluctuates week to week.
As per the IRS, employer payroll tax obligations are assessed per employee per period, which means per-employee pricing structures can create real budgeting headaches for shift-based teams.
The tools in this guide are organized by approach rather than ranked, and each section includes real G2 and Capterra ratings so you can weigh the options yourself.
If you're already leaning toward making a switch, the hard part usually isn't choosing — it's the migration. When you move to Homebase payroll, setup and data transfer are free, so you're not starting from scratch.
Why small business owners look for Gusto alternatives
Here are the four pain points that come up most often when small business owners go looking for Gusto alternatives.
Scheduling isn't built into Gusto's base plan
Gusto offers scheduling on its Plus and Premium plans, or as a paid add-on to its base plan. For businesses that need scheduling, time tracking, and payroll connected from day one, that means either stepping up to a more expensive tier or running separate tools and manually reconciling the data before every pay run.
Per-employee pricing adds up for variable teams
For hourly businesses where team size shifts with the season or the week, per-employee pricing makes costs harder to predict. PTO management gets more complicated too, since accruals and requests are often split across separate tools.
Hourly teams need a mobile-first experience
Hourly teams live on their phones, not at desks, so when clock-in, schedule access, and payroll visibility aren't all in one app, you end up with missed punches, compliance gaps, and a lot of back-and-forth with employees who can't find the information they need.
What Gusto reviews say about customer support
Here's what Reddit has to say about Gusto alternatives — small business owners describe unresolved SSA discrepancies, pay rate errors applied to the wrong dates, and support tickets closed without resolution. Gusto reviews on G2 and Capterra echo the same theme: when something goes wrong with payroll, the support experience matters enormously, and it's become a recurring concern.
When juggling separate tools for scheduling, time tracking, and payroll is costing you hours every week, Homebase payroll connects all three in one app so nothing falls through the cracks.
The real cost of using the wrong payroll (it's more than the subscription)
Let's look at what using a payroll tool that isn’t the right fit actually costs a typical 10-person hourly business. The subscription price is just the starting point.
Subscription cost. Most payroll tools for small businesses run $480–$1,200 per year depending on the provider and plan tier, and that's before any add-ons come into play.
Hidden fees. Beyond the subscription, the extras add up fast:
- Setup fees: $0–$200+
- Per-run charges: $0–$10 per payroll run (up to $520/year for weekly payroll)
- Year-end W-2 and 1099 filing: $0–$200+
- Garnishment processing: $0–$30 per event
- Off-cycle runs for bonuses, corrections, or terminations: $0–$15 each
Time cost. Business owners spend an average of 5+ hours per month on payroll processing, according to a Homebase survey of 385 payroll customers. At a conservative $50/hour opportunity cost, that's $3,000 per year of your time — time you could spend on the floor, with customers, or not working.
Integration costs. Connecting separate scheduling, time tracking, and payroll tools typically adds $50–$150 per month in additional subscriptions. That's $600–$1,800 per year in tools that still don't talk to each other perfectly.
Error correction costs. According to the American Payroll Association, 40% of small businesses have been penalized for payroll errors, with correction costs reaching hundreds of dollars per incident. Those costs compound fast when manual data entry is part of your weekly process.
What this actually costs a 10-person hourly team
Add it all up for a typical 10-person hourly business, and wrong-fit payroll can easily cost $4,000–$6,000 per year beyond what you expected. The SBA estimates that federal paperwork compliance alone costs small businesses tens of billions of dollars annually — and payroll is a significant part of that burden.
5 Approaches to payroll for small businesses with hourly teams
Not all payroll tools work the same way, and the right approach depends on how your team operates, not just which Gusto alternatives have the best reviews. Here are five approaches small businesses use to run payroll, along with the tools that fit each one, real ratings from G2 and Capterra, and honest takes from actual users.
1. All-in-one scheduling, time tracking, and payroll
For hourly teams, this is the approach that eliminates the most friction. When scheduling, time tracking, and payroll live in the same app, hours flow from clock-out to payroll automatically — no manual exports, no reconciling data across tools before every pay run.
Best for: Small businesses that want one app handling everything from scheduling shifts to running payroll, without bouncing between tools.
How it works: Employees clock in and out from the same app where their schedule lives, and hours, tips, overtime, and breaks calculate automatically before flowing directly into payroll — no exports, no imports, no manual entry.
What to look for:
- Built-in scheduling
- A mobile time clock
- Automated tax filing
- Direct deposit
- Tip and overtime support
Homebase is built for exactly this approach. Payroll starts at $39/month + $6/employee and includes unlimited payroll runs, next-day direct deposit, and free setup and data transfer when you switch — with scheduling and time tracking built in, not bolted on.
Trade-offs: All-in-one tools may have fewer advanced HR modules or global payroll features than enterprise-focused tools. If you have a large HR team or employees in multiple countries, you may need something with more depth.
Keeping your scheduling, time tracking, and payroll in one place cuts out the manual work between pay runs. Try Homebase free to see how the whole workflow connects.
2. Standalone payroll with manual time imports
This approach makes sense if you've already built a time tracking or scheduling workflow you're happy with and don't want to replace it. You keep the tools you know and add a dedicated payroll processor on top — but the connection between them is manual.
Best for: Businesses that already have a time tracking or scheduling tool they trust and just need a reliable processor to handle the payroll side.
How it works: You export hours from your time tracking app, import them into your payroll tool, review, and run. Most tools support CSV imports and direct integrations with common time tracking apps.
What to look for:
- CSV import support
- Automated tax filing
- Direct deposit
- W-2/1099 handling
OnPay (G2: 4.8/5) is a strong fit here. Users on G2 highlight:
- Flat-fee pricing ($49/month + $6/employee) with no hidden charges
- Consistently responsive US-based customer support
The downsides, according to reviewers:
- Limited new feature development in recent years
- No native international payroll support
Patriot Payroll is worth a look too if you have a very small team and want to keep costs as low as possible.
Trade-offs: Manual data transfers between tools create room for input errors. You're also managing multiple subscriptions, logins, and support relationships. When something breaks on payday, it's not always obvious which tool is responsible.
3. Payroll through your POS system
If your business already runs on a point-of-sale system, adding payroll through the same vendor can feel like the path of least resistance. Sales data, employee hours, and tips are all in one place — and payroll becomes one more function your POS handles rather than a separate system to manage.
Best for: Restaurants and retail shops that already run their entire operation through a single point-of-sale system and want payroll to work within the same ecosystem.
What to look for:
- Tight integration between your POS and payroll
- Tip pooling support
- Sales-to-labor cost reporting
Square Payroll fits this approach. Here's what reviewers on G2 and Capterra say:
- Users who already run Square POS praise the seamless pull of hours and tips into payroll with minimal setup
- Square Payroll's HR features are limited compared to standalone tools
- The tool loses most of its appeal if you're not already running Square as your POS
Trade-offs: You're locked into one vendor for your core operations. If you ever switch POS systems, your payroll goes with it. And if Square's payroll or POS pricing changes, your options are limited.
4. Accountant-managed payroll
Some small business owners don't want to run payroll themselves at all — and if you already have a trusted bookkeeper or CPA, handing it off entirely is a legitimate option. The trade-off is visibility and control, not cost savings.
Best for: Business owners who'd rather focus on running their business than managing payroll themselves, and already have a trusted financial professional in their corner.
Your accountant runs payroll on your behalf using their preferred tools — often ADP, QuickBooks, or a similar product built for accountant-facing workflows. Before you hand it off, make sure you have:
- A clear handoff process for submitting hours each pay period
- A firm submission timeline so payroll never runs late
- Transparent fees that account for off-cycle runs, amendments, and year-end filings
Trade-offs: You're dependent on someone else's schedule and systems. If your accountant is unavailable, your payroll is too. You also have less visibility into what's happening between pay runs, which can make it harder to catch errors before payday.
5. Enterprise HR suites scaled down
These tools were built for larger organizations and include payroll as one module inside a broader HR system. Some small businesses grow into them — but many end up paying for capabilities like performance management, advanced analytics, and global payroll that a 10-person restaurant or retail shop will never use.
Best for: Businesses that need all of the following alongside payroll, and are willing to pay for depth they may not fully use right away:
- Benefits administration
- Performance reviews
- Detailed compliance tools
Here's how the main tools in this category compare, based on G2 and Capterra reviews:
Rippling (G2: 4.8/5, 12,500+ reviews)
- Users love: Genuinely unified HR, payroll, IT provisioning, and benefits in a single interface
- Watch out for: Opaque modular pricing that's hard to pin down until you're in a sales conversation, and a steep initial setup curve
ADP Run (~4.5/5 on G2)
- Users love: Deep payroll tax compliance and benchmarking analytics built on decades of employer data
- Watch out for: A dated interface, difficult post-implementation support, and pricing that requires a direct quote
Paychex (4.1/5 on G2)
- Users love: 24/7 phone access and dedicated account managers for compliance-heavy situations
- Watch out for: Add-on costs for benefits, time tracking, and HR training that stack up quickly beyond the base price
Note: Paychex completed its acquisition of Paycor in April 2025. Both currently operate on separate platforms with their own service teams, but anyone evaluating either product should know they're now under the same parent company.
BambooHR (~4.4/5 on G2 and Capterra)
- Users love: Clean, intuitive interface and strong tools for performance management and hiring and onboarding
- Watch out for: Payroll and time tracking are add-on modules rather than included features, which pushes the total cost up for teams that need both
Trade-offs: These tools cost more, take longer to implement, and have a steeper learning curve than simpler options. They're built for organizations with dedicated HR teams, and many small businesses end up paying for depth they don't actually need.
How to pick the right payroll software for small business teams
The right payroll approach isn't about which tool has the most features or the best marketing. It's about matching the way you actually run your business. These three questions will get you most of the way there.
How does your team track hours right now?
If you're using paper time cards, a group text, or a spreadsheet, you're probably spending more time reconciling hours before each pay run than you realize. A tool that connects time tracking and payroll automatically removes that step entirely. If you're already using a dedicated time tracking app you love, a standalone payroll processor that imports from it may be all you need.
How often do you run payroll?
Hourly teams often run weekly or biweekly payroll, which means the per-run fees on some tools add up fast. A tool that includes unlimited payroll runs for a flat monthly fee is almost always a better deal for hourly businesses than one that charges per cycle. Check the fine print before you commit.
What else is eating your time besides payroll?
If scheduling, time-off requests, and team communication are also pulling you away from running your business, an all-in-one tool will give you a much bigger return than a payroll-only processor. The goal isn't to have the best payroll tool — it's to have fewer tools overall.
Finding the right payroll fit for your hourly team
For most hourly businesses in restaurants, retail, and similar industries, the questions that matter most are simple: how does your team track hours, how often are you running payroll, and how many separate tools are you willing to manage? The fewer the answers point toward "manually" and "multiple," the stronger the case for an all-in-one tool that keeps everything connected.
"With Homebase and Clover, running payroll takes five minutes. I log in, check the time cards, hit submit, and it's done." — Tiana Post, owner of Awaken Bakery
If you're spending hours every week juggling separate tools for scheduling, time tracking, and payroll for small business, Homebase puts all of it in one app.
Try scheduling and time tracking for free and see how it works before adding on payroll.
{{banner-cta}}
Frequently asked questions about Gusto alternatives
Who are Gusto's main competitors?
Gusto's main competitors include Homebase, OnPay, Square Payroll, ADP Run, Paychex, and Rippling — the most commonly compared payroll companies like Gusto for small businesses. Each takes a different approach, from all-in-one tools for hourly teams to full HR suites for larger organizations. The best fit depends on your team size and how you track hours.
What's similar to Gusto?
Tools similar to Gusto include OnPay and Patriot Payroll, both of which handle payroll processing and tax filing as a standalone service. For hourly teams that also need scheduling and time tracking, Homebase offers those features built into one app alongside payroll, so hours flow straight from the time clock to payday without manual entry in between.
What is the most affordable payroll service for small businesses?
The most affordable payroll services for small businesses include Patriot Payroll (starting around $17/month + $4/employee for the basic plan), OnPay ($49/month + $6/employee), and Homebase ($39/month + $6/employee with scheduling and time tracking included). The cheapest option depends on what's bundled in, since add-on fees can make a low-sticker tool expensive in practice.
Is Gusto the best payroll tool for small businesses?
Gusto is a strong payroll tool for salaried, remote-first teams, but it's not always the best fit for hourly operations. When comparing Gusto vs Homebase, the core difference is integration: Homebase vs Gusto comes down to whether scheduling, time tracking, and payroll are connected in one app or spread across separate tools and plan upgrades.
