What is internal hiring?
Internal hiring refers to the process of filling open positions at your business by promoting or transferring existing employees instead of recruiting from outside. Whether it’s giving a shift lead the opportunity to become an assistant manager or offering a cross-department role to someone looking for growth, internal hiring helps you leverage the talent you already have.
For small business owners, internal hiring is often one of the easiest ways to reward loyal team members, reduce hiring costs, and retain your best people. If you’re ready to make hiring and team management more organized, sign up for Homebase to simplify everything from hiring to onboarding and scheduling.
Why internal hiring matters for small businesses
It can feel natural to post your job openings publicly right away—but looking inside your own team first has real advantages:
- Reduces hiring time and costs – No need to advertise or go through lengthy external recruiting processes.
- Boosts retention – Giving employees opportunities to grow helps keep them engaged and loyal.
- Improves morale – Promoting from within shows your team that hard work and dedication are recognized.
- Increases productivity – Existing employees already understand your business, culture, and tools.
- Minimizes training time – Internal candidates often require less ramp-up because they’re familiar with your systems.
When you make it clear that there’s room to grow at your business, you’re more likely to keep your top talent around for the long haul.
Examples of internal hiring
Internal hiring can take several forms, including:
- Promotions – Moving an employee up to a higher position (e.g., shift lead to assistant manager).
- Lateral transfers – Moving an employee to a different role at the same level (e.g., front-of-house to back-of-house operations).
- Temporary assignments – Giving current employees short-term projects or leadership roles to build experience.
- Internal job postings – Sharing open roles with your team before advertising externally.
Even small businesses with tight teams can benefit from internal hiring by giving people a chance to take on more responsibility.
How to approach internal hiring effectively
- Create a clear process – Outline how employees can apply for internal positions and what qualifications are required.
- Communicate transparently – Let your team know about open roles and how to express interest.
- Stay fair and objective – Evaluate internal candidates consistently, just as you would external applicants.
- Provide constructive feedback – If an internal candidate isn’t selected, offer support and guidance for future opportunities.
- Support training and development – Give employees the tools they need to grow into new roles successfully.
Treat your internal hiring process with the same level of care as your external hiring. Clear communication helps avoid misunderstandings and keeps morale high.
Pros and cons of internal hiring
Pros:
- Faster time-to-fill for open positions
- Lower recruitment costs
- Higher retention rates and team loyalty
- Less training needed due to existing company knowledge
Cons:
- May limit fresh ideas and outside perspectives
- Can cause tension if internal candidates feel overlooked
- May require backfilling the employee’s previous role
The best approach often involves a healthy balance of internal promotion and external recruitment.
Common mistakes to avoid with internal hiring
- Skipping a formal process – Don’t rely on informal promotions or "gut feeling" alone.
- Ignoring outside candidates completely – For some specialized roles, external experience may still be valuable.
- Failing to communicate clearly – Lack of transparency can lead to confusion or resentment.
- Not preparing internal candidates for success – Promotion without support can lead to frustration or failure in the new role.
The key is to have a structured, supportive approach that helps your employees feel valued and set up for success.
How Homebase helps with internal hiring and team development
Homebase makes hiring, scheduling, and team management easier for small business owners. Whether you’re promoting from within or bringing on new talent, our tools help you:
- Post internal job openings and track candidate interest
- Manage team scheduling and role changes easily
- Keep employee records and job history organized
- Onboard promoted employees with digital checklists and forms
- Stay compliant with labor laws and best practices
Explore Homebase’s hiring and onboarding tools to make internal hiring simple, fair, and effective—so you can build a stronger team from the inside out.
Related articles
Payroll Manager Job Description: What They Do and Why You Need One