Free Payroll Apps for Small Business: How They Work & What to Expect

Running a small business means watching every dollar. When you're juggling rent, inventory, and payroll, those monthly software subscriptions can feel like a luxury you can't afford. Free payroll apps seem like an obvious solution, but could "free" apps end up costing you more?

Many business owners learn this the hard way. They start with a free payroll app, only to discover they need to pay extra for essential features like direct deposit or tax forms. 

Others spend hours handling tasks manually that paid software would automate. Worst of all, some face expensive penalties from payroll mistakes their free app didn't catch.

In this article, let’s explore what free payroll apps can really do for your business and when they might end up costing you more than they save.

{{banner-cta}}

What is a free payroll app?

Free payroll apps are basic software tools that help you calculate wages and manage employee payments without a monthly subscription fee. While they can handle essential tasks like calculating gross wages and tax withholdings, they typically skip the automation that makes payroll processing truly simple. 

Most free payroll apps don’t offer automatic tax filing or compliance monitoring. Instead, you’ll just get the basic tools to help you do the math.

How can I do payroll for free?

Running your own payroll means becoming your own payroll department. Let's walk through what that actually involves.

First, you'll need to get set up with the government. This means registering for your Federal Employer Identification Number (EIN), state tax ID numbers, and state unemployment insurance accounts. Depending on your location, you might also need local tax registrations.

Before you can process your first payroll, you'll need to collect and organize essential paperwork from your employees:

• W-4 forms for tax withholding
• I-9 forms verifying work eligibility
• State tax withholding forms
• Direct deposit authorization forms
• Benefits enrollment documentation

Setting up a structured payroll system comes next. Create a regular payroll schedule—whether that's weekly, biweekly, or monthly. You’ll also need to consult your state’s payroll distribution rules. While some are quite flexible with these rules, like Alabama or Florida, some require businesses to pay employees on a strict set schedule. 

You'll want a separate bank account for payroll and a reliable system for tracking hours worked. Document your pay policies clearly, especially regarding overtime and breaks.

The actual payroll calculation process is where free apps can help, but there's still work involved. You'll need to:

• Track regular hours and overtime.
• Calculate gross wages.
• Determine correct tax withholdings.
• Process any deductions.
• Calculate final net pay.

What about tax payments and deposits? Here's where free apps often leave you on your own. You're responsible for handling all tax payments and deposits correctly (the penalties for mistakes can be costly). Every payroll means managing:

• Federal income tax withholding.
• Social Security and Medicare (FICA) taxes.
• Federal unemployment tax (FUTA).
• State income tax withholding.
• State unemployment insurance.
• Any local taxes.

Remember: These payments have strict deadlines. Miss one, and you're looking at penalties that could wipe out any savings from using free software.

After this comes record-keeping. You'll need to maintain detailed records of all payroll transactions, tax deposits and filings, employee time records, and any changes to pay rates. 

Keep those deduction authorizations and tax forms organized too. You might need them years down the road for tax or legal purposes.

How does free payroll software work?

Here's the typical process:

Enter employee information. 

Before you can run your first payroll, you'll need to input all the basics: pay rates, tax info, and payment details for each employee.

Calculate wages & taxes. 

The software helps with math, but you'll still need to verify everything. It'll calculate gross pay based on hours worked or salary, then figure out tax withholdings and deductions. Just remember to double-check those tax rates, they change more often than you might think.

Pay employees. 

Some free apps offer direct deposit, but many just create payment records. That means you're handling the actual money movement through manual direct deposits or writing checks.

Generate tax forms & reports. 

Free software gives you the essentials—pay stubs and basic tax documents. But filing those forms? That's usually on you.The key difference between free and paid software? Automation. Free apps provide tools for calculations, but you'll do most of the legwork. Paid solutions automate the entire process.

Pros and cons of using free payroll apps

What can (and can’t) free payroll apps do for your business? Here’s a detailed look. 

Pros

Lowers business expenses. 

No monthly software fees means more cash for other business needs, like hiring, marketing, or inventory. This can make a huge difference in your early stages when watching every dollar counts. 

Simplifies payroll calculations. 

Stop wrestling with spreadsheet formulas. Free apps handle basic payroll math—from calculating wages to determining tax withholdings. This reduces manual errors and helps ensure your team gets paid accurately.

Supports small teams and contractors. 

When you're just starting out or only paying yourself, free payroll apps can be enough. With fewer tax considerations and simpler compliance needs, these tools often cover the basics for very small teams.

Provides basic record-keeping. 

Most free payroll services help you generate basic payroll reports and maintain payment records. While they won't file your taxes, they'll help you track what you need for year-end reporting. 

Cons

Limited features. 

Unlike paid payroll solutions, free apps usually don't include the automation that makes payroll truly simple, like automatic tax filing or benefits administration. That means you'll handle tax payments, compliance paperwork, and most filing manually.

Requires manual work. 

While these apps help with calculations, you're still handling tax deposits, compliance checks, and payment processing on your own. All this manual work increases your risk of costly mistakes—and sleepless nights!

May include hidden costs. 

Watch out for surprise fees. Need direct deposit? That might cost extra. Want help with tax filing? There's probably a fee for that. Need customer support? You might have to pay. These "hidden" costs add up fast.

Not scalable for growing businesses. 

As your team grows, payroll gets more complex. Free apps often can't handle multi-state tax filing, benefits administration, or changing labor laws. You'll likely need to switch to paid software eventually—it's just a question of when.

Who should use free payroll apps

Not every business needs premium payroll software. Free apps might be perfect if you're:

New small businesses testing payroll software. 

New small business owners often need to test different payroll approaches before committing to a paid solution. Free payroll software lets you learn the basics and understand your needs before investing in more robust options.

Freelancers and sole proprietors. 

Freelancers and sole proprietors usually have simpler payroll needs. If you're just paying yourself, free apps can handle the basic calculations and help you track earnings for tax time.

Businesses with very few employees. 

Got one or two employees? Free payroll apps might handle your needs just fine. As long as you're willing to manage tax filings and payments separately, these tools can work for very small teams.

But watch out—free payroll programs aren't for everyone. Here's when you should probably skip them:

You have multiple employees and need automated payroll processing. 

More employees mean more complexity. Tracking different work hours, calculating various overtime rates, and ensuring everyone gets paid correctly gets overwhelming fast with manual processes. 

Paid payroll software like Homebase automates these tasks, reducing errors and saving you valuable time.

You need state and federal tax filings handled for you. 

Most free apps leave you hanging when it comes to tax filing. You'll need to calculate withholdings correctly, keep up with changing tax laws, and make timely deposits to tax agencies. Miss a deadline? That's on you. 

You want to minimize compliance risks. 

Payroll isn't just about paying people—it's about following labor laws, minimum wage requirements, and classification rules. Free apps usually don't help here, leaving you vulnerable to expensive mistakes. 

On the other hand, paid software often includes compliance alerts and legal support to help you avoid common pitfalls.

You need additional payroll features like benefits and garnishments. 

Health insurance deductions? 401(k) contributions? Wage garnishments? Free apps often struggle with these extras. 

Paid solutions handle these automatically, saving you from complex calculations.

Free payroll apps vs. paid payroll software: What’s the difference?

Let's break down what you really get (and give up) with free payroll apps:

Cost

Free payroll

Nothing's really free in business—especially software. While free payroll apps skip the monthly subscription fee (making them tempting for budget-conscious businesses), the reality is more complicated.

Free apps often use a "freemium" model. Basic calculations? Sure, those are free. But essential features like direct deposit, tax form generation, or customer support usually come with price tags. 

Need to pay more than a few employees? There might be user limits. Want to file taxes through the platform? That's often a premium feature.

Paid payroll

Paid payroll software typically offers transparent pricing. You'll pay a base monthly fee plus a per-employee charge, but you know exactly what you're getting. Most include features like direct deposit, tax filing, and customer support in their base price. 

While paid payroll is a bigger upfront cost, it often works out cheaper than dealing with the hidden fees and limitations of "free" options.

Think about it this way: if your free app charges $5 per direct deposit, $10 for each tax form, and $20 for support calls, you could easily spend more than a paid solution's monthly fee—without getting the automation and peace of mind that comes with it.

Tax filing

Free payroll

Here's where the difference really hits home. Free apps typically stop at calculating your tax withholdings—leaving you to handle the actual filing process. 

That means tracking multiple tax deadlines, staying current with changing rates, and manually submitting payments to federal, state, and local agencies all by yourself.

Paid payroll

Paid software takes this burden off your plate. It automatically calculates, files, and pays your payroll taxes. 

Many even guarantee their calculations, meaning they'll cover any penalties if something goes wrong. When tax laws change (and they do, frequently), your software updates automatically.

Direct deposit

Free payroll

Want to skip the hassle of printing and signing checks? With free apps, that might cost you. 

Many either don't offer direct deposit or charge per transaction. Some require you to handle the bank transfers manually—adding another task to your list.

Paid payroll

Paid solutions include direct deposit as a standard feature. Your employees get paid automatically, often with options for same-day or next-day processing. 

Plus, you get features like splitting payments between accounts or offering pay cards—options that free apps rarely provide.

Compliance support

Free payroll

This is a big one. Running payroll means following a maze of labor laws, tax regulations, and reporting requirements. 

Free apps usually leave you to figure this out on your own. If you miss a deadline or miscalculate overtime? That's your responsibility.

Paid payroll

Paid payroll software acts like your personal compliance assistant. It updates automatically when laws change, flags potential issues before they become problems, and often provides access to HR experts who can answer your questions. 

Some even offer liability protection—if they make a mistake, they'll handle the penalties.

Customer support

Free payroll

When payroll questions come up (and they will), free apps often leave you searching for answers. 

You might get access to basic help articles or community forums, but good luck getting someone on the phone without paying extra.

Paid payroll

Paid software includes real support from actual payroll experts. Whether you need help setting up deductions, handling a garnishment, or fixing a tax issue, you can reach someone who knows what they're talking about. 

Many offer multiple support channels—phone, email, chat—so you can get help your way.

How to choose the right free payroll app

If you've decided to try a free payroll app, here's how to pick one that won't cause headaches down the road:

Decide what’s most important

Before you start comparing apps, know what you can't live without. Need basic tax calculations? Employee time tracking? Direct deposit capabilities? List your non-negotiables so you don't get caught without essential features halfway through payroll.

Compare features. 

Free apps vary wildly in what they actually offer. Some provide solid tax calculations and basic reporting, while others might just be glorified spreadsheets. Compare their features carefully—especially the ones you'll use most often.

Check for hidden costs. 

What looks free today might cost you tomorrow. Check for charges on:

• Direct deposit processing.
• Tax form generation.
• Adding multiple employees.
• Customer support access.
• Report downloads.

Remember: Paying for good software upfront is often cheaper than getting nickel-and-dimed by "small" fees.

Look at customer support options. 

Before you commit, try reaching out to customer support. How long do they take to respond? Are basic questions included in the free tier? Nothing's worse than being stuck with a payroll problem and no help in sight.

Test a free trial. 

Most payroll providers offer free trials of their paid versions. This gives you a chance to test premium features and see what you'd be missing with the free version. Run a sample payroll or two—you might find the paid features are worth the investment.

Not sure where to start? Read our breakdown of the top 5 free payroll apps for small businesses to find the right fit for your needs.

How Homebase can help you run payroll

Want payroll that actually makes your life easier? Homebase combines the tools you use every day—scheduling, time tracking, and team communication—with powerful payroll features that grow with your business.

Skip the manual work and hidden fees. With Homebase, you get:

• Automatic time tracking to payroll conversion.
• Built-in tax filing and compliance support.
• Mobile app to run payroll whenever you want.
• Expert help when you need it.
• Clear, predictable pricing.

Ready to spend less time on paperwork and more time growing your business? Power up your payroll with Homebase. 

{{banner-cta}}

FAQs about free payroll apps

Can I run payroll for free?

Technically, yes. Free payroll apps can help with basic calculations and record-keeping. But remember: You'll still need to handle tax filings, compliance checks, and payment processing manually. 

Your time has value too—factor that in when deciding if "free" is really free.

Are free payroll apps actually free?

Most aren't 100% free. While basic calculations might cost nothing, essential features like direct deposit, tax forms, or customer support often come with fees. 

Read the fine print carefully, those small charges can add up quickly.

Do free payroll apps work for W-2 employees?

Free apps can handle basic wage calculations for W-2 employees, but they often struggle with the full picture. You'll likely need to manage tax withholdings, benefits deductions, and year-end W-2 preparation yourself or pay extra for these features.

What happens when my business grows?

As your team expands, free apps usually show their limitations. More employees mean more complexity: different pay rates, benefit deductions, multiple state taxes. 

Most businesses find they need to switch to paid software to handle these demands efficiently. Better to choose a solution that can grow with you from the start.