On-Call Scheduling: Software, Pay Rules & Best Practices

For many small businesses, on-call schedules are a necessary part of staying responsive and reliable. This is especially true for fast-paced retail, restaurant, and field service teams, who depend on last-minute coverage when the unexpected strikes.

But when on-call scheduling isn’t handled well, it can frustrate even the most seasoned employees and even create compliance risks. In this guide, we’ll dig into best practices for different on-call models, how to manage payroll, and the best on-call software that takes the stress out of scheduling for you and your team.

TL;DR: Understanding on-call scheduling

Need a quick look at the ins and outs of on-call scheduling? Here’s the key info.

What scheduling models are used for on-call management?

• Fixed on-call schedules: The same employee or role is consistently on call during a specific, scheduled window.
• On-call rotation schedule: Employees take turns being on call on a set cycle, such as weekly or biweekly.
• Follow-the-sun coverage: Remote team members across different time zones are available for on-call support to avoid the need for overnight shifts.
• Hybrid models: Businesses primarily use scheduled shifts, but have on-call coverage available for backup during peak hours.

How does on-call pay typically work?

• On-call standby pay is paid separately from actual hours worked
• On-call time is unpaid unless employees are working
• Compensable if employees must respond immediately, remain on-site, or have less control over how they use personal time

What should you look for in the best on-call scheduling software?

• Automated rotations
• Clearly visible availability and time-off periods
• Mobile notifications and alerts
• Real-time schedule changes
• Payroll and time tracking tool integration

{{banner-cta}}

What is on-call scheduling?

On-call scheduling is a staffing approach where employees are available to work as needed during a set time, even though they’re not scheduled for a specific shift. These employees fill crucial staffing gaps for businesses that would struggle to function if demand changed rapidly or an emergency came up.

Common on-call roles include:

• Nurses and medical technicians
• IT support and system administrators
• Field service, maintenance, or repair workers
• Restaurant managers
• Retail shift leads

Businesses use on-call schedules to stay flexible and keep operations smooth without overstaffing or inflating labor costs. That means consistent service for customers and peace of mind for owners and staff.

What does it mean when a job is “on call”?

When a job is “on call,” it means an employee isn’t actively working but must be available during a defined time. This usually applies to overnights, weekends, or business-specific high-demand windows. For example, during wintertime, snow plow operators and plumbers might be on an on-call rotation to help manage the roads or frozen pipes as needed.

Response time is a key part of on-call management. Depending on the role, employees may be expected to answer a call within minutes or report on-site within an hour. If your business operates in person, location requirements should be clearly defined so there aren’t delays in coverage.

Compensation rules vary, but might include on-call pay, higher hourly rates when called in, or minimum shift guarantees. When hiring employees for on-call roles, be sure to make it clear that there aren’t going to be guaranteed hours or pay. 

How on-call scheduling works in practice

On-call scheduling looks different depending on the industry, but most systems follow a similar structure to make sure someone is always available:

On-call rotations

An on-call rotation model spreads responsibility across a team by assigning coverage in a repeating pattern, such as weekly, biweekly, or daily shifts. Unpredictable scheduling often contributes to employee turnover.

While on-call scheduling is unpredictable by nature, having rotations scheduled makes it easier for employees to plan their paid time off and manage work-life balance.

Primary vs. secondary on-call coverage

Many businesses use a primary and secondary on-call system to add an extra layer of backup coverage. The primary on-call employee is contacted first, but the secondary steps in if the primary doesn’t respond or needs extra support during a busy period.

This takes the burden off of a single on-call employee to save the day, and gives business owners extra cushion when things don’t go according to plan.

Coverage windows

Coverage windows define exactly when on-call availability is required, like overnight hours, weekends, or holiday scheduling. Clear coverage windows help employees understand when they’re expected to be reachable and allow businesses to have coverage at the ready without bloating labor costs.

Escalation when someone doesn’t respond

Escalation rules outline what happens if an on-call employee doesn’t respond within the expected timeframe. This might mean contacting a secondary employee, notifying a manager, or triggering an automated alert so issues don’t go unresolved.

Automated on-call scheduling software makes it so that escalations don’t become emergencies, just another part of the on-call management process.

On-call scheduling models and rotations

The right on-call scheduling model depends on your hours, business needs, staffing levels, and how often on-call coverage is actually needed.

These are the models that are commonly used when creating call schedules:

Fixed on-call schedules

A fixed on-call schedule assigns the same employee or role to be on call during specific times on an ongoing basis. For example, a small retail business might have the store manager on call every Sunday evening to handle call-outs or urgent issues.

If the manager is salaried, both labor costs and team back-up stay consistent no matter what the evening rush looks like.

Rotating on-call schedules

Rotating schedules move on-call responsibility between employees on a set cycle, such as weekly or biweekly. A maintenance team, for instance, might rotate on-call duties each week so everyone shares after-hours coverage evenly. This model of on-call rotation stays on top of customer support without burning out employees.

Follow-the-sun coverage

For remote teams, follow-the-sun coverage makes use of employees in different time zones to provide on-call support without overnight shifts.

For example, an IT support company might rely on staff in different regions to handle issues during their normal working hours. This removes the risk of response delays, and lets employees across the world work “normal” business hours.

Hybrid models

Hybrid models combine scheduled shifts with on-call coverage as a backup when demand spikes or emergencies occur. A restaurant might schedule a full staff for peak hours, but still keep one experienced shift lead on call in case of a callout.

How does on-call pay typically work?

On-call pay can be tricky, and generally varies based on when someone is available vs. actively called in to work. For example, not all on-call employees are paid for being on call. On-call pay usually falls into several categories:

• Standby pay vs. hours worked: Standby pay compensates employees simply for being available during a scheduled on-call period, even if no work occurs. Hours worked are paid separately, typically at a higher rate, once the employee is called in and actually performs tasks.
• Paid vs. unpaid on-call time: If the business allows employees to use on-call time freely (for example, staying home or running errands), it may be unpaid.
• When on-call time becomes compensable: Time is compensable when employees must respond immediately, remain near or on-site, or have limited ability to use their personal time.
• Overtime considerations: Depending on total weekly hours and labor laws, work performed during on-call periods might count towards overtime.

State labor laws, industry standards, and union agreements may impact how your business is allowed to handle on-call duty scheduling. Be sure to research local regulations so you’re up to date with wage compliance.

Watch out for these challenges with on-call scheduling

On-call scheduling can be a lifesaver in a pinch, but it comes with its fair share of challenges:

• Burnout and fairness issues. Uneven on-call rotations or frequent last-minute call-ins can quickly lead to employee fatigue and resentment. Fair and consistent scheduling helps maintain employee morale and reduces turnover.
• Manual scheduling errors. Spreadsheets or paper schedules are recipes for scheduling misunderstandings and double bookings. Automated on-call scheduling software gets rid of those errors and saves you time playing Tetris with schedules.
• Lack of visibility into employee availability. If managers don’t know who’s actually available, it’s easy to call the wrong person or create scheduling conflicts instead of fixing them.
• Missed alerts or coverage gaps. Even the best schedules fail if no one’s paying attention to alerts. Mobile on-call scheduling software should come with push notifications, and clear escalation protocols are necessary for low-stress backup.
• Poor communication. Call duty scheduling can be confusing, especially for first-time employees. Clear instructions, transparent policies and expectations, and consistent updates make the on-call model a problem solver instead of a problem creator.

On-call scheduling software: what to look for

On-call scheduling software tools go beyond basic calendars, offering features that help teams stay aligned and responsive. Less mistakes, less confusion.

But what’s the best software for on-call scheduling? The answer depends on your business, but there are some key features that benefit everyone.

Automated rotations

Automated rotations handle the heavy lifting of assigning on-call shifts fairly across your team. Instead of manually tracking who’s up next from week to week, your on-call software automatically creates your schedule based on rules you set in advance.

This reduces admin burnout and room for errors, all while keeping coverage predictable for you and your employees.

Availability and time-off visibility

No one wants to check in about availability over and over. On-call scheduling software should give managers a clear view of each employee’s availability in one place. This includes both approved time off and blackout periods.

This prevents frustrating double-booking accidents and makes it easier for everyone to schedule around personal commitments. With 75% of hourly workers saying that work-life balance is the most important part of job satisfaction, time off is no joke.

Notifications and alerts

Automatic schedule notifications let employees know when they’re on call or if coverage suddenly changes. Mobile alerts for missed responses or upcoming shifts keep everyone accountable and help avoid stressful coverage gaps.

Schedule changes in real time

On-call roles exist when your business needs tend to change fast. For restaurant, retail, IT, and field service industries, when you need another hand, you need it stat.

If your on-call software doesn’t let managers update schedules easily, then it’s not worth having. Look for reliable software that helps employees know that they’re always working with the most current plan, and can jump into a shift with minimal confusion.

Integration with payroll and time tracking

The best on-call scheduling software should connect directly with time-tracking and payroll systems. Automatically logging hours and inputting them into payroll tools streamlines your processes, ensures compliance with wage and hour laws, and reduces administrative headaches for both managers and employees.

Best on-call scheduling software and tools

Curious about your options for the best on-call scheduling software? Here’s a look at how a few of our favorite options suit different business needs.

Automated on-call scheduling tools

No matter the business, automating routine tasks is your friend. Plug in employee availability and enjoy a cup of coffee while your software generates a schedule that could’ve taken you hours.

Our top picks for automated on-call software include:

• Shiftboard: Comes with industry-specific scenarios, auto-blocks scheduling against employment laws and internal policies, and distributes overtime based on employee scheduling history.
• Connecteam: An all-in-one app with drag-and-drop AI scheduling, shift-swapping features, and GPS tracking. Fully HIPAA-compliant messaging tools are also available for healthcare teams.
• Hypercare: Designed for healthcare, Hypercare keeps teams connected by combining on-call scheduling with a virtual pager and secure messaging.

On-call scheduling software for hourly teams

Hourly teams come with unique challenges, like last-minute coverage changes, fluctuating availability, and payroll considerations.

These tools help managers fill gaps fast without endless text follow-ups:

• Homebase: Combines scheduling, availability tracking, time clocks, team messaging, and payroll in one place. Small business managers automatically build schedules and streamline every step that follows, keeping hourly staff members in sync with their shifts.
• 7shifts: Includes availability tracking, open shift pickup, coverage alerts, and task management tools. Commonly used by restaurant franchises.
• BrightHR: More HR focused, BrightHR’s open scheduling tools include real-time alerts and automated schedule changes for timesheets. Also comes with labor cost tracking features.

Free or lightweight on-call scheduling tools

If you’re tight on funds, just getting started out, or have a very small team, free software can be a great jumping off point.

These free plans can cover your bases as you grow:

• Connecteam: “Free for Life” plan offers core scheduling and on-call features at no cost for small teams, plus built-in chat and notifications. Free for up to 10 users.
• Sling: Best for small teams with basic on-call needs, Sling offers simple but effective shift planning and employee messaging tools. Free for up to 30 users.

IT-focused on-call tools

IT-focused on-call software should make sure alerts reach the right person at the right time—especially when outages or incidents strike outside normal hours:

• PagerDuty: Manages size-appropriate rotations, first and secondary responders, and timezone coverage for global IT teams. Primarily focuses on incident management.
• Amtelco: Supports complex rotations, detailed reporting, and automated real-time updates. Ideal for call centers and large organizations with multiple departments.

Free on-call scheduling software: what works and what doesn’t

If your small business is just getting off the ground, free on-call scheduling tools can be a good place to start.

Free scheduling software usually includes:

• Basic shift creation with calendar views
• Simple rotation management
• Manual availability tracking
• Team notifications via email or app

However, are your team grows, you might notice limits like:

• A lack of real-time alerts
• Limited automated rotation features
• Minimal reporting or analytics
• Less streamlined systems

If you start banging into more coverage mistakes or find yourself texting on-call employees rather than using the app, it’s worth it to upgrade. Investing in paid software with automation, alerts, and analytics can save time and reduce stress for everyone.

How to set up an on-call schedule that actually works

On-call management is about creating a system that reduces burnout and helps you retain team members for the long haul. With these scheduling best practices, you can create a fair and sustainable workplace.

Define expectations clearly

“On-call” looks different from business to business, so be clear about:

• Availability windows
• Response time expectations
• Compensation policies
• Location requirements
• On-call rotation structures

If you’re working with scheduling software, set up a paid training for employees to learn how to use it and ask any questions that come up. Clarity around systems and expectations makes it easier for people to do their jobs without confusion or frustration.

Rotate fairly

When it comes to scheduling, there are words to watch out for: “I feel like I’m always the one who’s on call.”

When things feel unfair, morale can drop fast. Work with an on-call rotation system that spreads duties evenly across your team, and avoid repeatedly assigning the same person late nights or holidays. Even if their availability is most frequently open, they shouldn’t take on the most undesirable hours all the time.

It’s usually not possible to give everyone exactly what they want, but keeping preferences in mind builds trust with employees.

Track availability

It sounds simple, but it’s worth repeating: keep a real-time record of who’s available, including approved time off and blackout periods. An app with an employee self-service portal is a lifesaver for time-off requests. Employees are less stressed when they know the schedule reflects their actual availability.

Set response time standards

Clear expectations around response times are crucial for ensuring urgent issues are handled without delays. Make sure employees know the window in which they’re expected to answer their phone, report to a site, or log into a system.

Escalation procedures should also be a part of this conversation so secondary employees know what to expect, too.

Review and adjust regularly

Your call duty scheduling probably won’t be perfect on the first try. Gather feedback from your team and track any coverage gaps or burnout patterns so you can adjust rotations, windows, and response expectations.

It might be uncomfortable to hear that staff members are frustrated with your systems, but try not to get defensive. Incorporating their feedback is key for cultivating trust and overall employee happiness.

Navigating on-call management with your team

On-call scheduling doesn’t have to be a headache. With structured rotations, clear rules around pay, and open communication, you can build a system that works for both your business and your team.

And don’t forget—automated on-call scheduling software can do the crunchiest parts of the work. Leave the group chats for your social life and swap over to an app to help you track availability, manage alerts, and respond fast to emergencies.

Looking for an app that does all this and payroll too? Shoot us a message today to see what Homebase can do for your hourly team.

{{banner-cta}}