Best Payroll Calculators For Small Businesses (2026)

Running payroll for your team shouldn't feel like a math final. But one miscalculation—overtime, taxes, tips—can cost you hundreds of dollars and a whole lot of trust. Whether you're running payroll for the first time or just tired of second-guessing your numbers, the right payroll calculator makes the difference between payday confidence and payday panic. 

This guide breaks down the best payroll calculators available right now, from free tools to all-in-one solutions that do the math so you don't have to.

Best payroll calculators, explained

The best payroll calculator depends on your team's complexity and how much time you want to spend on payroll:

• For quick federal tax estimates: IRS paycheck calculator
• For hourly teams with tips and overtime: Homebase payroll, which automates payroll calculations after you set up payroll—there's no standalone calculator
• For salary vs. hourly comparisons: Gusto paycheck calculator
• For state-specific tax breakdowns: SmartAsset paycheck calculator
• For QuickBooks users: QuickBooks payroll calculator

Free calculators work for simple paychecks. But when you're managing multiple roles, tips, or overtime, automated payroll software eliminates guesswork and saves hours every pay period.

What is a payroll calculator (and what it can and can't do)

A payroll calculator is a tool that helps you figure out how much to pay your team after taxes and deductions. You enter gross wages, and the calculator estimates federal income tax, Social Security, Medicare, and sometimes state and local taxes. Some calculators also factor in pre-tax deductions like health insurance or retirement contributions.

What most payroll calculators handle well:

• Gross to net pay conversions
• Federal tax withholdings (based on W-4 information)
• Social Security and Medicare calculations
• Basic state income tax estimates

What most payroll calculators struggle with:

• Tips and tip credits
• Multiple pay rates for the same employee
• Local and city-specific taxes
• Overtime calculations across different roles
• Multi-state compliance
• PTO accruals and tracking

Payroll calculators are useful for estimating a single paycheck or understanding tax withholdings. But they don't track hours, file taxes, or catch errors before they happen. If you're running payroll regularly for hourly teams—especially with tips, overtime, or varying schedules—a calculator becomes a starting point, not a solution. You'll still need to manually track time, verify calculations, and handle tax filings yourself.

How we evaluated the best payroll calculators

We've tested the most popular payroll calculators to see which ones actually deliver accurate results without making you hunt through tax tables or second-guess your math. Some are free and great for quick estimates. Others connect time tracking with payroll to eliminate manual entry entirely. Here's what works, what doesn't, and which tool makes sense for your team's size and pay structure.

• Accuracy and tax coverage: Does it handle federal, state, and local taxes correctly? Can it account for different filing statuses and withholding allowances?
• Ease of use: Can you get an accurate estimate in under two minutes, or does it require a tax degree to navigate?
• Support for hourly work: Does it calculate overtime properly? Can it handle tips, multiple pay rates, or shift differentials?
• Cost: Is it free, or does it require a subscription? Are there hidden limitations in the free version?
• Best use case: Who is this tool actually built for? A solo contractor estimating their own paycheck needs something different than a restaurant owner managing 15 hourly employees.

The best payroll calculator for your business depends on your team's size, pay structure, and how much time you're willing to spend on payroll math every week.

Homebase payroll calculator (best for small businesses with hourly teams)

Homebase doesn't offer a standalone payroll calculator. It's actually a complete payroll system that eliminates the need for one entirely. Employees can clock in and out using Homebase's free plan for basic time tracking. Once payroll is set up, Homebase automatically calculates hours, breaks, overtime, and wages based on tracked time. No manual entry. No spreadsheets. No "dividing by 60" at 11 PM on Sunday.

When payroll is active, Homebase calculates and files federal, state, and applicable local payroll taxes automatically. It tracks tips, manages multiple pay rates for employees who work different roles, and alerts you before someone hits overtime. If you're managing a restaurant, retail store, or any business with shift workers, Homebase connects time tracking with payroll so you're never manually calculating hours or rates.

You can start with Homebase's free plan to track time and manage schedules. When you're ready to run payroll, it's a seamless upgrade. Payroll customers can generate and file required forms like W-2s and 1099s, depending on worker classification. For teams with rotating shifts, tips, and unpredictable schedules, Homebase replaces payroll calculators with automation.

IRS paycheck calculator (best for federal tax estimates)

The IRS Tax Withholding Estimator is the most authoritative tool for federal tax calculations. It's built by the agency that actually collects your taxes, so the numbers are as accurate as you're going to get for federal withholding.

You'll enter your filing status, income, deductions, and credits, and the calculator estimates your federal income tax, Social Security, and Medicare withholdings. It's especially useful if you're checking whether your W-4 is set up correctly or if you want to avoid a surprise tax bill (or refund) at the end of the year.

What it doesn't do: state or local taxes, overtime calculations, or anything related to tips or multiple pay rates. It's also not designed for running actual payroll—it's a planning tool for individual employees or employers trying to understand federal withholding. If you need state tax estimates or you're calculating payroll for a full team, you'll need to supplement this with other tools.

ADP paycheck calculator (best for quick paycheck previews)

ADP's paycheck calculator is simple and fast. You enter gross pay, pay frequency, filing status, and state, and it gives you a net pay estimate in seconds. It covers federal and state income taxes; local taxes may vary by location.

It's useful for quick ballpark estimates—like when you're hiring someone new and want to show them what their take-home pay might look like, or when you're comparing salary offers. The interface is clean, and you don't need to create an account or enter sensitive business information.

The tradeoff: it doesn't handle tips, overtime, or multiple pay rates. It won't track your actual payroll or file taxes for you. It's a preview tool, not a payroll system. If you're already using ADP for payroll, their full platform handles these complexities. But the standalone calculator is best for one-off estimates, not ongoing payroll management.

Gusto paycheck calculator (best for salary + hourly comparisons)

Gusto's paycheck calculator is built for comparing salary and hourly pay structures. You can toggle between the two and see how take-home pay changes based on different pay frequencies, filing statuses, and state taxes.

It's particularly helpful if you're deciding whether to hire someone as salaried or hourly, or if you're explaining pay structures to new hires. The calculator includes federal and state taxes and breaks down each deduction clearly so you can see exactly where the money goes.

Like ADP, Gusto's calculator is designed for quick estimates. It doesn't calculate overtime, track hours, or manage tips. If you're already a Gusto payroll customer, their full platform handles these details. But the free calculator is meant for planning and comparison, not for running actual payroll. You'll still need to track time separately and manually enter hours if you're using this as a standalone tool.

QuickBooks payroll calculator (best for QuickBooks users)

If you're already using QuickBooks for accounting, their payroll calculator can help estimate payroll costs and tax withholdings. The calculator handles federal and state taxes and gives you a breakdown of employer costs—not just what your employee takes home, but what payroll actually costs your business when you factor in employer taxes. Integration with accounting data requires a QuickBooks Payroll subscription.

The calculator is useful for budgeting and forecasting, especially if you're planning to hire or give raises. You can see how payroll impacts your cash flow before making decisions.

The limitation: QuickBooks' free calculator is basic. It doesn't handle tips, overtime, or multiple pay rates unless you're using their full payroll service. For hourly teams with complex schedules, you'll need to manually track time and verify calculations. It's best for businesses already committed to the QuickBooks ecosystem who want payroll estimates that tie directly into their books.

SmartAsset paycheck calculator (best for state-specific taxes)

SmartAsset's paycheck calculator is one of the most detailed free tools for understanding state and local tax impacts. It includes many state and local taxes, though coverage varies by location—something many other free calculators skip entirely.

You enter your gross pay, filing status, and location, and SmartAsset breaks down federal, state, Social Security, Medicare, and local taxes line by line. It's especially useful if you're hiring remote workers in different states or if you're trying to understand how moving to a new state would affect your team's take-home pay.

What it doesn't do: overtime, tips, or multiple pay rates. It's a tax estimator, not a payroll processor. You'll still need to track hours, calculate overtime manually, and handle tax filings yourself. But for understanding the tax side of payroll—especially when state and local taxes get complicated—SmartAsset is one of the most thorough free options.

{{banner-cta}}

How to choose the best payroll calculator for your business

The best payroll calculator depends on your team's size, pay structure, and how much time you're willing to spend on payroll every week.

• Number of employees: If you're paying one or two people, a free calculator works fine. You can manually track hours, plug them into a calculator, and verify the math yourself. But once you hit five or ten employees—especially hourly workers with different schedules—manual calculations become a time sink. You'll spend hours every pay period just entering data and double-checking numbers.
• Hourly vs. salaried: Salaried employees are straightforward. The math is the same every paycheck. Hourly employees are more complex. You're tracking clock-ins, breaks, overtime, and sometimes multiple pay rates if someone works different roles. Free calculators don't handle this complexity well. You'll need to calculate overtime manually, verify hours against schedules, and hope you didn't miss anything.
• Tips, overtime, and multiple roles: If your team earns tips, works overtime, or gets paid different rates for different shifts, most free calculators won't help. They're built for simple paychecks, not the realities of restaurant, retail, or hospitality work. You'll need a tool that tracks tips accurately, calculates overtime across different pay rates, and adjusts for shift differentials without manual math.
• Multi-state compliance: If you have remote workers or locations in multiple states, payroll gets even more complicated. State and local tax rules vary wildly, and free calculators often oversimplify or miss local taxes entirely. A payroll system that updates automatically with tax law changes protects you from costly mistakes.
• Time spent vs. risk: The real question is whether the time you're spending on payroll math—and the risk of getting it wrong—is worth the cost of automation. If payroll takes you three hours every week and you're constantly second-guessing your numbers, a payroll system pays for itself.

Common payroll calculation mistakes (and how to avoid them)

Even with a calculator, payroll math is easy to get wrong. And when you do, it costs you—in money, time, and trust.

• Manual overtime math: Calculating overtime across multiple pay rates or overlapping workweeks is where most mistakes happen. You're juggling 1.5x rates, different hourly wages, and sometimes state-specific overtime rules. One missed calculation means underpaying or overpaying your team, and both create problems.
• Missed local taxes: Federal and state taxes are straightforward. Local and city taxes are not. Some cities impose their own income taxes, and free calculators often don't account for them. You think you've withheld correctly, and then you get a notice from the city saying you owe back taxes and penalties.
• Rounding errors: Rounding hours or wages might seem minor, but those pennies add up. And legally, you're required to pay employees for all time worked. Rounding down—even by a few minutes—can lead to wage theft claims and Department of Labor fines.
• Tip miscalculations: Tips are taxable income, and you're required to withhold taxes on them. But calculating tip credits, tracking declared tips, and ensuring compliance with tip pooling rules gets complicated fast. Manual calculations invite errors that put you at risk during audits.

The best way to avoid these mistakes is to remove yourself from the equation. Automated payroll systems calculate everything correctly, every time.

Payroll calculator FAQs

What is the most accurate payroll calculator?

The IRS Tax Withholding Estimator is the most accurate for federal taxes because it's built by the IRS. For overall payroll accuracy—including state and local taxes, overtime, and tips—payroll software like Homebase is more reliable than standalone calculators. Free calculators estimate, but they don't account for every variable or update automatically when tax laws change. If accuracy matters, automate.

Are payroll calculators free to use?

Most payroll calculators are free, including tools from the IRS, ADP, Gusto, SmartAsset, and QuickBooks. Homebase doesn't offer a standalone calculator—instead, it automates payroll calculations when you use its time tracking and payroll features. You can start with Homebase's free plan for basic time tracking, then add payroll when you're ready. Free calculators work for estimates, but they don't track time, file taxes, or handle payroll for you.

Can a payroll calculator handle overtime and tips?

Most free payroll calculators don't handle overtime or tips well. They're built for simple gross-to-net conversions, not the complexity of shift work. Once payroll is set up, Homebase automatically calculates overtime across multiple pay rates and tracks tips accurately—no calculator needed. If your team earns tips or regularly works overtime, a payroll system designed for hourly workers will save you time and prevent costly mistakes.

Do payroll calculators account for state and local taxes?

Most payroll calculators include state income taxes, but local and city taxes are hit-or-miss. SmartAsset's calculator is one of the most thorough for local tax coverage. Homebase updates payroll tax calculations for supported federal, state, and local jurisdictions as laws change, so you're always compliant without tracking tax law updates yourself. If you have employees in multiple states or cities with local taxes, automation is worth it.

When should I switch from a calculator to payroll software?

Switch when payroll takes more than an hour per pay period, or when you're managing tips, overtime, or multiple pay rates. If you're second-guessing your math or worrying about tax filings, payroll software eliminates the stress. With Homebase, your employees clock in and out, and payroll runs automatically with no calculator required. No spreadsheets, no manual entry, no crossing your fingers on payday.

Run payroll without doing the math

Payroll calculators are useful for quick estimates. But when you're running payroll every week for a team with tips, overtime, and rotating shifts, calculators become one more thing to manage.

With payroll enabled, Homebase calculates hours, wages, and taxes and files payroll taxes on your behalf. Your team clocks in and out, and the math happens automatically without spreadsheets or guesswork.

Taxes get filed on time, paychecks hit accounts when they should, and you stop spending Sunday nights with a calculator. Try Homebase payroll and see what it's like to run payroll without doing the math.

‍